Governors Voice
Grave Concerns on Immigration
Published: July 11, 2010 - New York Times
BOSTON — In a private meeting with White House officials this weekend,
Democratic governors voiced deep anxiety about the Obama administrationfs suit
against Arizonafs new immigration
law, worrying that it could cost a vulnerable Democratic
Party in the fall elections.
While the weak economy dominated the official agenda at the summer meeting
here of the National
Governors Association, concern over immigration policy pervaded the
closed-door session between Democratic governors and White House officials and
simmered throughout the three-day event.
At the Democratsf meeting on Saturday, some governors bemoaned the timing of
the Justice Department lawsuit, according to two governors who spoke anonymously
because the discussion was private.
gUniversally the governors are saying, eWefve got to talk about jobs,f h
Gov. Phil Bredesen of Tennessee, a Democrat, said in an interview. gAnd all of a
sudden we have immigration going on.h
He added, gIt is such a toxic subject, such an important time for Democrats.h
The administration seemed to be taking a carrot-and-stick approach on Sunday.
Homeland Security Secretary Janet
Napolitano, in town to give the governors a classified national security
briefing, met one-on-one with Jan
Brewer, the Republican who succeeded her as governor of Arizona and ardently
supports the immigration law.
About the same time as that meeting, Attorney General Eric
H. Holder Jr. said on a taped Sunday talk show that the Justice Department
could bring yet another lawsuit against Arizona if there is evidence that the
immigration law leads to racial profiling.
Ms. Brewer said she and Ms. Napolitano did not discuss the current lawsuit.
Instead, in a conversation she described as cordial, they discussed Arizonafs
request for more National Guard troops along the border with Mexico, as well as
other resources.
The Democratsf meeting provided a window on tensions between the White House
and states over the suit, which the Justice Department filed last week in
federal court in Phoenix. Nineteen Democratic governors are either leaving
office or seeking re-election this year, and Republicans see those seats as
crucial to swaying the 2012 presidential race.
The Arizona law — which Ms. Brewer signed in April and which, barring an
injunction, takes effect July 29 — makes it a crime to be an illegal immigrant
there. It also requires police officers to determine the immigration status of
people they stop for other offenses if there is a greasonable suspicionh that
they might be illegal immigrants.
The lawsuit contends that controlling immigration is a federal
responsibility, but polls suggest that a majority of Americans support the
Arizona law, or at least the concept of a state having a strong role in
immigration enforcement.
Republican governors at the Boston meeting were also critical of the lawsuit,
saying it infringed on statesf rights and rallying around Ms. Brewer, whose
presence spurred a raucous protest around the downtown hotel where the governors
gathered.
gIfd be willing to bet a lot of money that almost every state in America next
January is going to see a bill similar to Arizonafs,h said Gov. Dave Heineman of
Nebraska, a Republican seeking re-election.
But the unease of Democratic governors, seven of whom are seeking re-election
this year, was more striking.
gI might have chosen both a different tack and a different time,h said Gov.
Bill Ritter Jr. of Colorado, a Democrat who was facing a tough fight for
re-election and pulled out of the race earlier this year. gThis is an issue that
divides us politically, and Ifm hopeful that their strategy doesnft do that in a
way that makes it more difficult for candidates to get elected, particularly in
the West.h
The White House would not directly respond to reports of complaints from some
Democratic governors.
But David
Axelrod, the presidentfs senior adviser, said on Sunday on CNNfs gState of
the Unionh that the president remained committed to passing an immigration
overhaul, and that addressing the issue did not mean he was ignoring the
economy.
gThat doesnft mean we canft have a good, healthy debate about the economy and
other issues,h Mr. Axelrod said.
Mr. Obama addressed the economy last week during stops in Kansas City and Las
Vegas, and has been calling on Congress to offer additional tax relief to small
businesses.
And the heads of Mr. Obamafs national debt commission — Alan
K. Simpson and Erskine
B. Bowles — were on hand here on Sunday to press the economic issue.
The nationfs total federal debt next year is expected to exceed $14 trillion,
and Mr. Simpson, a former Republican senator from Wyoming, and Mr. Bowles, a
Democrat and the White House chief of staff under President Bill
Clinton, offered a gloomy assessment if spending is not brought under
control even more.
gThis debt is like a cancer,h Mr. Bowles said. gIt is truly going to destroy
the country from within.h
Still, the issue of immigration commanded as much attention as anything here
this weekend.
Ms. Brewer, who was trailed by television cameras all weekend, called the
lawsuit goutrageoush and said the state was receiving donations from around the
country to help fight it.
gI think Arizona will win,h she said, gand we will take a position for all of
America.h
Immigration was not the only topic at the Saturday meeting between Democratic
governors and two White House officials — Patrick Gaspard, Mr. Obamafs political
director, and Cecilia Munoz, director of intergovernmental affairs. But several
governors, including Christine
Gregoire of Washington, said it was a particularly heated issue.
Ms. Gregoire, who does not face an election this year, said the White House
was doing a poor job of showing the American public that it was working on the
problem of illegal immigration.
gThey described for me a list of things that they are doing to try and help
on that border,h Ms. Gregoire said of the White House officials at the
closed-door meeting. gAnd I said, eThe public doesnft know that.f h
She added, gWefve got a message void, and the only thing wefre hearing is
that theyfre filing a lawsuit.h
Some Democrats also joined Republicans in calling for Congress to pass an
immigration policy overhaul this year.
gThere are 535 members of Congress,h said Gov. Brian
Schweitzer of Montana, a Democrat. gCertainly somebody back there can chew
gum and hold the basketball at the same time. This is not an either-or.h
Gov. Bill
Richardson of New Mexico praised the Justice Departmentfs lawsuit, saying
his fellow Democratsf concerns were gmisguided.h
gPolicy-wise it makes sense,h said Mr. Richardson, who is Hispanic and who
leaves office this year on term limits, gand Obama is popular with Hispanic
voters and this is going to be a popular move with them nationally.h
Gov. Martin
OfMalley of Maryland — a Democrat who voiced apprehension about the lawsuit
in the private meeting, according to the two governors who requested anonymity —
said in an interview that he supported it.
gThe president doesnft have control over some of the timing of things that
happen,h Mr. OfMalley said. gWhen those things arise, you canft be too precious
about whatfs in it for your own personal political timing or even your partyfs
timing. When matters like this arise, I think the president has to take a
principled stand.h
But Mr. Bredesen said that in Tennessee, where the governorfs race will be
tight this year, Democratic candidates were already on the defensive about the
federal health care overhaul, and the suit against Arizona further weakened
them. In Tennessee, he said, Democratic candidates are already gdisavowingh the
immigration lawsuit.
gMaybe you do that when youfre strong,h he said of the suit, gand not when
therefs an election looming out there.h
Mr. Ritter of Colorado said he wished the Justice Department had waited to
sue Arizona until after the law went into effect, to give the public a chance to
see how difficult it would be to enforce.
gItfs just an easier case to make,h he said. gI just think that law
enforcement officers are going to have a terribly difficult time applying this
law in a constitutional way.h
Sheryl Gay Stolberg contributed reporting from Washington, and Katie Zezima
from Boston.